Author Tim Alberta appeared with Stephanie Ruhle to explain the psychology behind Evangelical Christians who support Donald Trump. He was promoting his new book. “The Kingdom, the Power, and the Glory: American Evangelicals in an Age of Extremism.”
Author Tim Alberta explains why evangelicals are Trumpers.
Podcasts (Video — Audio)
In his recent appearance on MSNBC’s The 11th Hour with Stephanie Ruhle, author Tim Alberta provided a thought-provoking analysis of the perplexing relationship between evangelical Christians and former President Donald Trump. Alberta’s insights, as outlined in his latest book, “The Kingdom, the Power, and the Glory: American Evangelicals in the Age of Extremism,” offer a comprehensive examination of why a group known for its religious and moral values embraced a figure whose behavior seemed at odds with those principles.
Alberta’s investigation begins by highlighting the surprising electoral support Donald Trump garnered from white Evangelical Protestant voters. Trump’s victory with 77% of this demographic in 2016, followed by an increase to 84% in 2020, raises the question of what drove evangelicals to rally behind a leader whose personal life and conduct often clashed with their deeply held beliefs.
The author’s personal journey and motivation for delving into this topic add a layer of authenticity to his analysis. As the son of an evangelical pastor, Alberta’s firsthand experience navigating the intersection of faith and politics informs his perspective. He explains that his quest to understand this phenomenon was triggered when he returned home for his father’s funeral and was met with church members more interested in political debates than honoring the memory of his late father. This pivotal moment prompted him to investigate the underlying reasons behind evangelicals’ ardent support for Trump.
One of the key factors Alberta highlights is the role of abortion in evangelical support for Trump. While many evangelicals may not be deeply invested in partisan politics, they view abortion as a profound ethical, moral, and spiritual issue. This perception leads them to prioritize this singular issue, aligning themselves with the political party that opposes abortion rights. In this way, the “red team” becomes their allies, while the “blue team” becomes their adversaries.
Ironically, Trump-supporting Evangelical Christians are obsessed with a fetus, yet when a baby is born, they object to policies that would make the lives of these children whole. Maybe more people would take them seriously if they were consistent in their morals.
Perhaps one of the most concerning aspects Alberta raises is the concept of Christian nationalism. He points out that a significant portion of evangelicals believes America to be a nation with a divine covenant with God. This belief leads them to conflate patriotism with religious devotion, a perspective that diverges from traditional Christian teachings. Alberta underscores the theological dangers of this viewpoint, emphasizing that true Christian citizenship is in heaven, not tied to any earthly nation.
Evangelical leadership should be ashamed of their role in shaping this narrative. Rank-and-file evangelical Christians follow their pastors. Shepherds, pastors, and leaders who have led their flocks astray must accept the responsibility for this metastasizing cancer. These leaders have created a psychological pathway that enables believers to rationalize support for a figure like Donald Trump despite his apparent divergence from Christian principles.
Tim Alberta’s analysis offers a comprehensive perspective on the intricate relationship between evangelical Christians and Donald Trump. His examination of the role of abortion, the dangers of Christian nationalism, and the responsibility of evangelical leadership sheds light on this complex and often baffling phenomenon. As we reflect on Alberta’s insights, it becomes evident that there is significant work ahead in addressing the divisions and challenges within this influential demographic. Understanding these dynamics is crucial for navigating the intersection of religion and politics in contemporary American society.
