President Trump boasts about having the best economic growth ever. Unfortunately, when a reality check was applied, even President Carter, with worldwide and domestic headwinds, had more growth.
Trump’s economic growth was less than President Carter’s
Podcasts (Video — Audio)
The political narrative surrounding former President Donald Trump often centers on his claim that he presided over the “greatest economy of all time.” Trump and his supporters frequently tout his handling of the economy as a monumental success. However, a closer inspection reveals that his economic performance, particularly in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) growth, pales compared to several post-war presidents, including Jimmy Carter.
This discussion notes that “even Carter had a better economy than Donald Trump.” This fact may surprise many people, particularly those who have internalized the relentless barrage of propaganda emanating from right-wing media outlets. While Trump’s economic growth is often overstated, a deep dive into the numbers demonstrates that his GDP growth, which he often flaunted as unparalleled, was the seventh best among post-World War II presidents. This is particularly true when contrasted with Jimmy Carter, president during significant economic turmoil, including the energy crisis and high inflation.
The Myth of Trump’s “Great Economy”
The Trump administration’s economic record is often framed around a booming stock market and low unemployment. These points, while factually correct to a degree, mask a far more complex reality. Trump inherited a strong economy from President Obama, who pulled the nation out of the Great Recession. During the Obama administration, the unemployment rate fell from 10% at its peak to 4.7% by the time he left office. This steady recovery provided Trump with a favorable economic landscape.
However, Trump’s boastful claims about unparalleled growth do not hold up to scrutiny. According to analysis from outlets like The New York Times, Trump’s GDP growth was modest compared to other post-war presidents, even before the pandemic ravaged the economy in 2020. His growth was slower than that of President Obama and Clinton and even slower than Jimmy Carter’s. The notion that Trump’s economy was the “best ever” is a myth perpetuated through media echo chambers that are reluctant to fact-check or challenge the narrative.
Carter vs. Trump: A Data-Driven Comparison
While Jimmy Carter’s presidency is often associated with economic challenges, such as stagflation, the truth is that the American economy during his term experienced solid growth. Under Carter, the GDP grew at an average rate of 3.3%, which, though not extraordinary, surpasses Trump’s pre-pandemic growth rate. Carter also presided over a period of deregulation in industries such as airlines and trucking, which laid the groundwork for future economic expansion. While inflation and high energy prices marred his legacy, Carter’s economic stewardship has been unfairly maligned, especially when juxtaposed against Trump’s exaggerated claims.
Trump’s GDP growth before the pandemic averaged around 2.5%, which places him behind many of his predecessors. This is notable, as Carter governed during a time of significant external challenges, including the oil embargo and geopolitical instability. Yet, despite these headwinds, his economic performance was still stronger than Trump’s pre-COVID numbers.
Media’s Role in Perpetuating the Myth
One of the points raised is the failure of mainstream media to challenge Trump’s economic rhetoric effectively. This highlights a broader issue: corporate media’s reluctance to push back against conservative narratives for fear of being labeled as biased. Trump’s constant attacks on the media as “fake news” created an environment where even factual corrections were often watered down or absent, giving rise to widespread misinformation.
Platforms like MSNBC, often perceived as more progressive, still failed to challenge Trump’s claims about the economy adequately. This allowed the narrative of the “greatest economy ever” to take root, even though data from sources like the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis contradicts this claim.
Critical thinking and fact-based reporting are essential to dismantling these falsehoods. When the media fails to counter baseless claims, the public is left vulnerable to manipulation, which, in Trump’s case, helped solidify a misleading narrative about his economic achievements.
The Progressive Solution: Amplifying Truth
The need for independent, progressive media platforms is more critical than ever. These outlets play an essential role in deconstructing the falsehoods propagated by mainstream media and right-wing commentators. The progressive message, which advocates for truth, transparency, and equitable economic policies, resonates with most Americans. However, it often struggles to gain the same level of exposure as conservative viewpoints.
Platforms like Politics Done Right serve as essential bulwarks against misinformation, offering a space where facts can be presented without fear of corporate or partisan interference. We must populate the internet with progressive content to shape honest public discourse.
Conclusion
The narrative that Trump presided over the greatest economy of all time is nothing more than a myth, one that has been debunked by careful analysis of GDP growth and other key economic indicators. As the transcript suggests, even Jimmy Carter, often derided for his handling of the economy, oversaw stronger GDP growth than Trump. The mainstream and independent media’s role in correcting these falsehoods is crucial to ensuring that the public is not misled.
For progressive activists and truth-seekers, the mission is clear: continue to challenge the lies, support independent media, and amplify the message of economic justice and factual reporting.
Viewers are encouraged to subscribe and join the conversation for more insightful commentary and to support progressive messages. Together, we can populate the internet with progressive messages that represent the true aspirations of most Americans.
