Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum rebuked DHS Secretary Kristi Noem’s hypocrisy and lying ads blaming migrants. Here is a reality Americans should know.
Mexico’s president lashes back at U.S. hypocrisy.
Watch Politics Done Right T.V. here.
Podcasts (Video — Audio)
Summary
Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum condemned U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem’s anti-migrant ads airing in Mexico, labeling them deceptive fear-mongering and proposing legislation to ban such foreign propaganda. Sheinbaum argued that Washington scapegoats Mexico for America’s fentanyl crisis and migration challenges, while ignoring U.S. demand for drugs and the southbound flow of U.S.-made guns that fuel cartel violence.
Key takeaways
- Sheinbaum moves to reinstate pre-2014 restrictions on foreign political ads after Noem’s spots call migrants “criminals” and “terrorists.”
- Ads spark outrage in Mexico for echoing Donald Trump’s racist 2015 rhetoric and violating national sovereignty.
- The host highlights U.S. responsibility for the fentanyl epidemic, noting that American demand, not Mexican supply, drives the trade.
- The host points to U.S.-sourced firearms crossing southward, arming cartels and undermining Mexican security.
- Sheinbaum calls for honest, reciprocal dialogue focused on reducing U.S. drug demand and tightening U.S. gun laws rather than exporting blame.
From a justice-oriented standpoint, Sheinbaum’s rebuke exposes how U.S. elites externalize the costs of deregulated capitalism—drug addiction, labor exploitation, and gun violence—onto their southern neighbor. Real solutions require investing in public health, living wages, and gun-safety reforms at home while partnering with Mexico on equitable development, not broadcasting xenophobic propaganda that distracts from America’s own policy failures.
Premium Content (Complimentary)
Mexico’s new president, Claudia Sheinbaum, has decided that her country will no longer serve as a billboard for Washington’s xenophobic theatrics. When U.S. Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem green-lit a blitz of television and YouTube spots in Mexico that branded asylum-seekers as “criminals,” “terrorists,” and “rapists,” the ads crossed a red-white-and-blue line that Mexicans have tolerated for too long. Sheinbaum responded by announcing legislation to restore the pre-2014 ban on foreign political propaganda, empowering regulators to pull the ads off the air and fine any station that dares to profit from them. The controversy reveals an old pattern: Washington externalizes America’s social ills while ignoring the economic and moral decay that fuels them at home.
The Department of Homeland Security argues that a $200 million media campaign is necessary to deter irregular migration. Yet the agency’s data show that border encounters are already falling to multiyear lows. Noem’s scaremongering, therefore, functions less as policy than election theater—an attempt to shift blame onto people whose only crime is desperation. Mexico’s decision to unplug the spots exposes a hypocrisy as old as the War on Drugs: U.S. politicians celebrate “personal responsibility” until the moment that responsibility falls on them. When overdoses soar, they blame Mexican cartels. When undocumented migrants flee poverty, they blame lax southern governments. However, they rarely examine the voracious American demand that fuels both crises.
Consider fentanyl. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates that more than 105,000 people died of drug overdoses in 2023, three-quarters of them involving synthetic opioids. Even with a welcome 24 percent decline in 2024, nearly 87,000 families still lost loved ones in a single year. Demand this large did not materialize because traffickers compelled unsuspecting citizens to snort powder; it grew out of decades of economic insecurity, untreated pain, and pharmaceutical profiteering. Federal analysts note that seizures along the southern border fell by roughly 20 percent last year and average pill potency dropped, suggesting supply already outstripped consumption. The bottleneck is not Mexican law-enforcement zeal; it is the United States’ unwillingness to treat addiction and inequality at their roots.
The gun trade flips the narrative. While DHS demonizes migrants on Mexican screens, the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives traces a torrent of American-made weapons southward. More than 50,000 U.S. firearms were smuggled into Mexico and Central America between 2015 and 2022, and the number of crime guns recovered in Mexico that trace back to U.S. dealers has jumped 63 percent since 2017. Grass-roots researchers estimate that roughly a quarter-million weapons cross the border from north to south each year, arming the very cartels U.S. politicians claim to fear. If reciprocity governed bilateral relations, Mexico could justifiably run hour-long infomercials on U.S. television condemning the lax gun laws that poison its communities. The outcry in Congress would rattle the dome of the Capitol.
Sheinbaum’s pushback, therefore, illuminates a more profound truth: the migration “crisis,” the opioid “crisis,” and the cartel “crisis” all begin with American appetites—cheap labor, mind-numbing relief, and lethal hardware. Republican leaders preach supply-side dogma: eliminate supply, and demand will wither. Reality laughs. Capital chases profit wherever demand exists. If migrants find no legal pathway, a smuggler emerges. If fentanyl disappears, methamphetamine rises. If assault-style rifles vanish, ghost-gun kits proliferate. Suppressing supply without shrinking demand merely drives commerce underground, enriching the violent actors Washington claims to fight.
A progressive alternative starts at home. Legalize status for the undocumented workers who already build U.S. prosperity; fair wages and labor protections would sap the coyotes’ recruiting pitch. Fund overdose-prevention centers, expand medication-assisted treatment, and regulate pharmaceutical advertising to address opioid demand rather than scapegoat foreign governments. Reinstate an assault-weapons ban and require universal background checks to dam the southbound river of guns. Finally, invest in Central American development and climate resilience so migration becomes a choice, not an exodus. Each of these steps places responsibility where it belongs: on the society that benefits most from the current disorder.
In silencing DHS’s fear-mongering commercials, Sheinbaum has not launched an attack on free speech; she has invited honesty. If U.S. leaders truly wish to end human smuggling and drug deaths, they must stop outsourcing blame and confront the profit engines on their own soil. Until then, no amount of slick propaganda aired abroad can hide the fact that America’s most dangerous addictions are not to fentanyl or migration but to denial and demagoguery.
Viewers are encouraged to subscribe and join the conversation for more insightful commentary and to support progressive messages. Together, we can populate the internet with progressive messages that represent the true aspirations of most Americans.
