CNN’s Brianna Keilar grilled Trump’s counterterrorism director, Sebastian Gorka, for scapegoating trans people and lying about his stats in his tweets, and giving false statistics on mass shootings.
Gorka melts down.
Watch Politics Done Right T.V. here.
Podcasts (Video — Audio)
Summary
On CNN’s State of the Union, Sebastian Gorka, former Trump counterterrorism official, attempted to spin a Minnesota mass shooting into an anti-trans narrative. Host Brianna Keilar pushed back forcefully with hard data, exposing Gorka’s distortions. While Gorka framed transgender people as a unique threat, the facts show the overwhelming majority of mass shooters are cisgender men. His response—rejecting data, narrowing definitions to fit his bias, and falling back on “local control” while excusing federal overreach elsewhere—revealed the hollowness of the Trumpist narrative.
- Gorka claimed transgender people drive a surge in mass shootings, despite data proving otherwise.
- CNN’s Brianna Keilar countered with U.S. Secret Service data: 96% of attackers are non-trans.
- Gorka dismissed statistics, accused CNN of “fake news,” and cherry-picked narrow cases to push his line.
- When asked about solutions, Gorka deflected, rejecting gun reform and cutting federal safety funding.
- The exchange highlights right-wing scapegoating of trans people to distract from the actual root causes: easy gun access, social alienation, and systemic policy failures.
The attempt to paint transgender Americans as the cause of mass shootings is not only dishonest—it is dangerous scapegoating that fuels violence against a marginalized community. Progressives recognize the real culprit: a society awash in firearms, coupled with right-wing politicians who block every attempt at sensible gun reform. The fight is not against vulnerable groups—it is against a political movement that puts ideology and profit above lives.
Premium Content (Complimentary)
Sebastian Gorka’s appearance on CNN’s “State of the Union” illustrates how the Trump-era playbook relies on deception, scapegoating, and authoritarian framing rather than the truth. In the wake of a tragic Minnesota mass shooting, Gorka sought to redirect public outrage away from America’s gun epidemic and toward an already-vulnerable community: transgender people. This calculated misdirection is not only factually baseless but politically corrosive, sowing division where unity and solutions are needed.
CNN host Brianna Keilar’s pushback mattered. She brought forward the U.S. Secret Service’s National Threat Assessment Center report, which examined 172 incidents between 2016 and 2020. That study revealed that 96% of attackers were not transgender. This should have ended the discussion. Yet Gorka, like many in Trump’s orbit, refused facts. Instead, he discredited the data, distorted definitions, and demanded an artificially narrow lens—restricting analysis to shootings at Christian and Catholic schools. By constructing this selective framework, Gorka sought to inflate the presence of trans shooters while erasing the broader reality: mass shooters are overwhelmingly cisgender white men, often radicalized in right-wing spaces or burdened by misogynistic, racist, or personal grievances.
This rhetorical manipulation mirrors the broader MAGA strategy of scapegoating minorities to distract from structural failings. Instead of addressing gun access—the common denominator in all these tragedies—Gorka insists on blaming “confusion about gender.” Instead of confronting the social alienation, extremism, and policy failures that fuel violence, he attacks marginalized identities. This is political opportunism designed to inflame fear, not reduce violence.
Gorka’s hypocrisy became even clearer when solutions were raised. He dismissed funding cuts made under Trump’s Department of Homeland Security, brushed off federal responsibility, and instead called for “local control.” Yet this same movement champions federal intrusion when it comes to abortion rights, policing cities with National Guard troops, or banning classroom discussions of race and gender. “Local control” becomes nothing more than a convenient talking point when it means shirking responsibility for national failures, while “federal control” becomes the rule when imposing authoritarian cultural policies.
Most revealing was Gorka’s fallback to the NRA’s tired talking point: more guns in more hands. He argued that arming parishioners and teachers would save lives, a claim belied by the hard truth. Armed civilians rarely stop mass shooters; instead, increased proliferation only escalates chaos and bloodshed. Research consistently shows that countries with fewer guns suffer fewer mass shootings. The United States, with its uniquely lax gun laws, has a uniquely catastrophic gun violence crisis. This is not a coincidence—it is causality.
The progressive response must be clear: reject scapegoating, confront the root causes, and advance policy grounded in evidence. That means expanding funding for mental health, reversing DHS cuts to threat assessment programs, and—most critically—passing strong federal gun safety legislation, from universal background checks to banning assault weapons. It also means calling out the deliberate bigotry embedded in narratives like Gorka’s. Transgender Americans are not threats to public safety; they are fellow citizens under threat from political propaganda that demonizes their existence.
Independent media plays a critical role here. Mainstream outlets too often allow figures like Gorka to launder misinformation unchallenged. In this case, CNN’s pushback was notable, but the broader media landscape remains tilted toward a false equivalence of both sides. That is why independent, fact-driven journalism is essential. When corporate media hesitate to confront lies out of fear of offending political elites, grassroots and independent platforms must take on the task of shedding light on the truth.
Ultimately, the real danger to America is not trans people—it is a political movement willing to distort facts, scapegoat the vulnerable, and ignore systemic gun violence to protect profits and power. Until that dishonesty is confronted head-on, the cycle of tragedy will continue. Progressives know that breaking it requires honesty, solidarity, and courage to stand with the marginalized rather than demonize them.
